Dashboard

Find out your home's maximum potential in today's market.

Compare the price of your Keys home to our recently sold listings. Price is a moving target that changes daily. You can’t afford to wait—we will get your property listed and sold for top dollar before the market shifts.

Click Here to Get Your FREE
Competitive Market Analysis

The real-estate market is constantly evolving and were ready to add your home to our SOLD list.

The Florida Keys real estate market presents a continuous challenge for accurate valuation. Many sellers rely on static price estimations that simply fail to reflect current market realities. At Dawn McComish Real Estate, we have eliminated the guesswork from pricing your dream home.

Our team, composed of top-performing Realtors, strategic data analysts, and a dedicated marketing force, meticulously examines extensive past sales throughout the Florida Keys. We leverage this comprehensive analysis to pinpoint the most competitive pricing strategies for your unique property.

We replace outdated information with unassailable facts. We delve into current sales performance within your specific community, factoring in location, waterfront access, size, specialized amenities, and prevailing market metrics. This precision allows us to identify the ideal price point for attracting qualified buyers and securing the maximum value for your property.

By partnering with Dawn McComish, a recognized HGTV House Hunters® Realtor, and our team of experts, you guarantee your Florida Keys home is positioned to sell promptly and achieve the maximum financial result.

Dawn’s Sold Properties In The Florida Keys

Address Location Price Listing Date Sold Date Agent Beds Baths Footage
389 Anglers Dr Unit 107 Marathon, FL $485,000 April 3, 2026 May 14, 2026 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 938
6800 Maloney Ave Lot 11 Stock Island, FL $260,000 January 30, 2026 May 11, 2026 Dawn McComish PA 3 1 2574
106 Southard St APT 9 Key West, FL $675,000 October 22, 2025 March 25, 2026 Dawn McComish PA 1 1 –
1113 Watson St Key West, FL $1,300,000 January 19, 2026 March 20, 2026 Dawn McComish PA 5 3 4,000
55 Boca Chica Rd Lot 56 Key West, FL $321,700 September 2, 2025 February 27, 2026 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 2,260
94825 Overseas Hwy #174 BIg Coppit Key, FL $1,150,000 November 8, 2025 February 26, 2026 Dawn McComish PA 3 3 1,658
3231 Pompano St BIg Pine Key, FL $635,000 January 12, 2026 February 19, 2026 Dawn McComish PA 2 1 10,000
1525 Von Phister St Key West, Fl $1,600,000 October 10, 2025 February 17, 2026 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 4,698
24830 Park Dr Summerland Key, FL $700,000 January 6, 2026 January 29, 2026 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 6,000
6850 Overseas Hwy #101 Marathon, FL $650,000 June 1, 2025 January 19, 2026 Dawn McComish PA 3 3 –
3978 Gordon Rd Big Pine Key, FL $780,000 October 3, 2025 November 13, 2025 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 5,250
142 Redwing Road Tavernier, FL $ 2,100,000 08/04/2025 09/07/25 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,705
109 South Layton Drive Layton, FL $ 1,058,000 07/09/2025 09/11/25 Dawn McComish PA 4 3 1,488
276 89th Street Ocean Marathon, FL $ 990,000 04/08/2025 08/29/24 Dawn McComish PA 4 2 1,577
4 Kyle Way West Marathon, FL $ 575,000 03/27/2025 07/22/25 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 959
9922 Aviation Boulevard Marathon, FL $ 1,500,000 02/25/2025 07/31/25 Dawn McComish PA 4 4 0
3231 Pompano Street Big Pine Key, FL $ 615,000 02/19/2025 08/04/25 Dawn McComish PA 2 1 864
28080 Curlew Avenue Big Pine Key, FL $ 1,150,000 01/28/2025 06/04/25 Dawn McComish PA 4 2 1,927
3530 Duck Avenue Key West, FL $ 875,000 01/23/2025 05/29/25 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,331
97501 Overseas Highway 709 Key Largo, FL $ 950,000 01/16/2025 07/16/25 Dawn McComish PA 3 3 2,396
150 12th Street Key Colony Beach, FL $ 3,610,000 12/28/2024 07/13/25 Dawn McComish PA 5 3 5,567
29374 Saratoga Avenue Big Pine Key, FL $ 935,000 12/22/2024 06/29/25 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,120
130 9th Street Key Colony Beach, FL $ 1,350,000 12/05/2024 02/27/25 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,599
3930 South Roosevelt Boulevard E304 Key West, FL $ 580,000 11/08/2024 02/20/25 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,068
27230 Brown Drive Ramrod Key, FL $ 730,000 10/31/2024 03/20/25 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,242
103 Shore Drive Summerland Key, FL $ 1,050,000 10/31/2024 01/02/25 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,128
52 Coral Way Key West, FL $ 1,150,000 09/30/2024 12/26/24 Dawn McComish PA 3 3 1,392
538 Sombrero Beach Road Marathon, FL $ 1,610,000 09/12/2024 04/10/25 Dawn McComish PA 2 3 1,344
12399 Overseas Highway #56 Marathon, FL $ 218,000 06/19/2024 08/01/25 Dawn McComish PA – – 0
97 Coco Plum Drive C35 Marathon, FL $ 82,500 06/19/2024 10/22/24 Dawn McComish PA – – 0
12399 Overseas Highway 56 Marathon, FL $ 209,900 06/19/2024 — Dawn McComish PA – – 0
97501 Overseas Highway 709 Key Largo, FL $ 1,250,000 06/11/2024 — Dawn McComish PA 3 3 2,396
3530 Duck Avenue Key West, FL $ 1,350,000 06/01/2024 — Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,331
1001 West Ocean Drive 1-208 Key Colony Beach, FL $ 650,000 05/27/2024 07/09/24 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,352
1904 Staples Avenue Key West, FL $ 835,000 05/03/2024 — Dawn McComish PA 3 3 1,160
1904 Staples Avenue Key West, FL $ 790,000 05/02/2024 03/12/25 Dawn McComish PA 3 3 1,160
381 Avenue C Key West, FL $ 786,000 05/02/2024 08/22/24 Dawn McComish PA 4 2 1,378
31124 Avenue C Big Pine Key, FL $ 570,000 04/14/2024 05/29/24 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 960
451 4th Street Key Colony Beach, FL $ 1,599,999 03/02/2024 — Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,155
29374 Saratoga Avenue Big Pine Key, FL $ 1,150,000 03/01/2024 — Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,106
808 Olivia Street Key West, FL $ 1,900,000 02/28/2024 05/15/24 Dawn McComish PA 3 3 1,763
30325 Eagle Lane Big Pine Key, FL $ 1,005,000 02/26/2024 04/10/24 Dawn McComish PA – – 0
234 Pescayo Avenue Marathon, FL $ 2,425,000 02/10/2024 05/08/24 Dawn McComish PA 3 3 2,201
3639 Gulfstream Street Big Pine Key, FL $ 760,000 01/15/2024 03/06/24 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,056
3930 South Roosevelt Boulevard W212 Key West, FL $ 520,000 12/31/2023 02/14/24 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 795
3618 Tradewinds Street Big Pine Key, FL $ 699,000 12/21/2023 02/14/24 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 894
1124 De Lussan Lane Cudjoe Key, FL $ 1,200,000 12/09/2023 01/18/24 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,397
205 South Point Drive Summerland Key, FL $ 2,375,000 12/01/2023 — Dawn McComish PA 5 4 2,772
6099 Overseas Highway 86E Marathon, FL $ 310,000 11/11/2023 03/13/24 Dawn McComish PA – – 1,133
13 Mccoy Circle #13 Key West, FL $ 1,100,000 10/20/2023 12/22/23 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,237
35 Sombrero Blvd #A3 Marathon, FL $ 360,000 09/01/2023 10/05/23 Dawn McComish PA – – 0
33 Bay Drive Key West, FL $ 1,050,000 08/20/2023 11/16/23 Dawn McComish PA 3 3 2,181
1321 20th Street Key West, FL $ 700,000 08/09/2023 10/15/23 Dawn McComish PA 2 1 836
130 9th Street Key Colony Beach, FL $ 1,445,000 08/03/2023 — Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,599
11890 1st Avenue Gulf 3 Marathon, FL $ 2,750,000 07/12/2023 11/09/23 Dawn McComish PA 5 4 2,607
11890 1st Ave #9 Marathon, FL $ 2,750,000 07/12/2023 11/08/23 Dawn McComish PA 5 4 2,607
28129 Dorothy Avenue Little Torch Key, FL $ 740,000 06/28/2023 08/14/23 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,334
2600 Overseas Highway #65 Marathon, FL $ 590,000 05/31/2023 09/26/23 Dawn McComish PA 2 3 850
390 13th Street Key Colony Beach, FL $ 10,500,000 05/02/2023 — Dawn McComish PA 5 5 4,215
50 Spoonbill Way Key West, FL $ 1,100,000 04/27/2023 09/19/23 Dawn McComish PA 3 3 1,320
65 7th Street Key Colony, FL $ 1,020,000 04/12/2023 06/18/23 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,400
1218 Grinnell Street Key West, FL $ 2,300,000 03/12/2023 05/04/23 Dawn McComish PA 4 4 4,032
29439 Saratoga Avenue Big Pine Key, FL $ 2,200,000 03/03/2023 — Dawn McComish PA 4 4 2,808
Seaview Avenue Duck Key, FL $ 1,140,000 02/28/2023 04/10/23 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,287
1215 Duncan Street Key West, FL $ 1,500,000 02/16/2023 03/28/23 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,050
1901 South Roosevelt Boulevard Apt 107E Key West, FL $ 705,000 02/04/2023 03/15/23 Dawn McComish PA 1 1 956
1901 South Roosevelt Boulevard Apt 106W Key West, FL $ 820,000 01/31/2023 03/23/23 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,099
2201 Staples Avenue Key West, FL $ 1,400,000 01/17/2023 01/30/24 Dawn McComish PA 5 5 3,898
100 Coco Plum Drive Marathon, FL $ 1,750,000 01/08/2023 07/06/23 Dawn McComish PA 4 3 2,376
701 Spanish Main Drive #149 Cudjoe Key, FL $ 400,000 01/08/2023 02/09/23 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 864
701 Spanish Main Drive #149 Cudjoe Key, FL $ 400,000 01/08/2023 02/09/23 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 864
200 12th Street Marathon, FL $ 2,550,000 11/17/2022 03/29/23 Dawn McComish PA 3 4 2,422
2000 Manor Lane Marathon, FL $ 2,850,000 11/07/2022 03/02/23 Dawn McComish PA 6 5 4,230
3841 North Roosevelt Boulevard #321 Key West, FL $ 1,095,000 10/18/2022 11/29/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 3 1,357
581 East Ocean Drive Apt32 Key Colony Beach, FL $ 520,000 10/04/2022 11/28/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,197
5950 Peninsular Avenue #673 Key West, FL $ 650,000 10/02/2022 10/23/22 Dawn McComish PA – – 0
1017 Simonton Street #103 Key West, FL $ 1,100,000 09/14/2022 01/16/23 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,242
332 Calzada de Bougainvillea Marathon, FL $ 800,000 07/01/2022 08/11/22 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,408
2662 Yellowtail Drive Marathon, FL $ 1,255,000 06/30/2022 10/31/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,295
321 9th Street Key Colony Beach, FL $ 1,232,610 06/29/2022 09/21/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 3 1,540
Lot 13th St Key Colony Beach, FL $ 525,000 06/01/2022 06/16/22 Dawn McComish PA – – 0
3841 North Roosevelt Boulevard #316 Key West, FL $ 1,000,000 05/23/2022 06/27/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,357
1901 South Roosevelt Boulevard #108 Key West, FL $ 975,000 04/27/2022 08/02/22 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,395
670 11th Street Marathon, FL $ 1,135,000 03/21/2022 06/29/22 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,392
670 11th Street Marathon, FL $ 1,135,000 03/21/2022 06/29/22 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,392
549 95th Street Marathon, FL $ 725,000 03/20/2022 05/18/22 Dawn McComish PA 3 3 1,779
2600 Overseas Highway #65 Marathon, FL $ 549,000 02/21/2022 04/18/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 1 850
12690 Overseas Highway Apt31 Marathon, FL $ 1,050,000 02/21/2022 03/31/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,387
107 Avenue D Apt 211 Marathon, FL $ 385,000 02/16/2022 03/24/22 Dawn McComish PA 1 1 600
220 11th Street Marathon, FL $ 1,030,000 02/16/2022 03/23/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,213
1001 West Ocean Drive #2206 Key Colony Beach, FL $ 750,000 01/25/2022 03/30/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,375
109 Avenue D Apt 312 Marathon, FL $ 359,000 01/23/2022 03/27/22 Dawn McComish PA 1 1 600
201 Coppitt Road 104C Big Coppitt Key, FL $ 265,000 01/18/2022 03/06/22 Dawn McComish PA 1 1 536
1001 West Ocean Drive 2-201 Key Colony Beach, FL $ 699,000 01/11/2022 03/17/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,375
3481 North Roosevelt Boulevard #226 Key West, FL $ 869,000 12/28/2021 03/10/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,357
27035 Dolphin Road Ramrod Key, FL $ 590,000 12/09/2021 04/11/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 1 912
81801 Overseas Highway #735 Islamorada, FL $ 465,000 11/09/2021 09/29/22 Dawn McComish PA 1 1 358
2600 Overseas Highway #1 Marathon, FL $ 840,000 10/28/2021 03/23/22 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 850
81801 Overseas Highway #737 Islamorada, FL $ 475,000 10/02/2021 03/10/22 Dawn McComish PA 1 1 550
94220 Overseas Highway 9F Tavernier, FL $ 620,000 09/14/2021 01/30/22 Dawn McComish PA 3 2 1,640
2000 Manor Lane Marathon, FL $ 1,750,000 09/12/2021 11/14/21 Dawn McComish PA 6 4 4,230
488 88th Street Ocean Marathon, FL $ 1,150,000 04/18/2021 06/20/21 Dawn McComish PA 6 4 2,465
701 Spanish Main Drive #240 Cudjoe Key, FL $ 240,000 02/01/2021 04/22/21 Dawn McComish PA – – 2,273
1901 South Roosevelt Boulevard Key West, FL $ 705,000 – 03/23/23 Dawn McComish PA 2 2 1,099

 

 

Schedule A Consultation

 

Schedule a private chat with Dawn to get the "on-the-ground" truth about the Florida Keys market. Whether you’re hunting for a waterfront retreat or getting ready to sell, Dawn skips the standard sales pitch and delivers the private intelligence you need to make the right move.

Not sure if the timing is right? Reach out for a free, no-obligation home valuation to see exactly where your property stands in today’s market. As a Top 1% specialist, Dawn works closely with you to protect your investment and—for sellers—uses a national marketing reach to ensure you walk away with top dollar. Reach out today and let’s find your version of paradise.

Connect With Dawn

Florida Keys and Key West real estate offer a life built around the water. I’m here to help you navigate it. Whether you are buying your first island getaway or selling a legacy estate, you deserve an advocate who is recognized on the national stage; you need more than a listing agent—you need a local authority with 25 years of "on the ground" experience. The Florida Keys have attracted the world’s most celebrated artists, athletes, writers, and leaders for over a century, and you deserve the best representation as well.

Featured on HGTV House Hunters: My work as a featured agent on House Hunters allows me to showcase the best of the Keys to a global audience, giving my sellers' properties unrivaled exposure.

A National Voice for Keys Real Estate: From Fox Business to top-tier luxury publications, I am the go-to resource for the tax advantages and lifestyle shifts driving today’s market.

25 Years of Local Insight: I don't just pull listings; I provide deep-sea knowledge of every reef, wreck, and residential pocket from Key Largo to Key West.