Dashboard

Expert Guidance For Buyers and Sellers

Real Estate Expert Dawn McComish – 25 Years Buying and Selling in Keys Paradise

“First and foremost, I consider myself a concierge realtor: I help you to arrange everything needed. For buyers, I can arrange lenders, prequalification letters, inspections, insurance, and more. For sellers, I provide professional photos, videos, local, National & International marketing, a dedicated website for your property, staging, title, and more. I have a team dedicated to making sure your transaction is smooth, and walk you through everything personally, from the offer to closing.”Featured Link to FOX Business Article

Dawn McComish, P.A.

Featured on HGTV
The ‘Singing Realtor’

 

With over 25 years of experience in the Florida Keys, Dawn McComish has cultivated a prestigious reputation built on deep local expertise and unwavering integrity. As a top-producing agent, she pairs her analytical understanding of Key West market trends with a vast professional network of developers, contractors, and lenders. This powerful combination grants her clients exclusive access to off-market listings and the “on-the-ground” intelligence necessary to navigate the unique complexities of island real estate, from historic property due diligence to waterfront zoning.

Dawn’s approach is defined by a “concierge-level” commitment to customer service, ensuring every transaction is as seamless and stress-free as possible. Known for her high-energy and transparent communication, she goes beyond the standard sales pitch to provide personalized guidance rooted in her clients’ specific lifestyles. Whether you are buying a vacation retreat or selling a high-value estate, Dawn’s results-driven strategy and elite marketing reach ensure your property receives maximum exposure while protecting your long-term investment.

 

Realtor Dawn McComish Profile

Get Your Listing Featured To The Right Audience

 

Your home is presented to an affluent, upscale national audience through prestige media brands like the Wall Street Journal, The Robb Report, and many more. Learn about real estate expert strategies we use to find the perfect buyers and list the highest valued homes.

New York Times
UPMKT Homes
mansion global
google earth maps
chicago tribune
wall street journal
IMLS listing service
JUWAII
the robb report

Working With Dawn

Dawn McComish is a skilled real estate professional known for her high-energy and results-driven approach. With years of experience in the Key West market, Dawn and her team have a deep understanding of market trends needed to list your house for maximum value. She uses her focus, determination, and analytical skills to benefit her clients and believes in the power of a positive mindset. She often cites her own resilience and determination during difficult times as the driving forces behind her success as one of the top-producing agents at her brokerage. 

Dawn attributes her success to her effective bespoke relationships with her clients and team. Dawn’s first priority is always to have open and honest communication about her client’s particular needs and lifestyles. Finding the right property isn’t always easy, and selling a home can prove to be challenging; however, you’ll find life-long personal satisfaction with her dedication to your property.

Above all, Dawn is passionate about improving the lives of her clients and securing the right property to bring fulfillment– knowing they made the right decision in hiring her team. She understands the value of a real estate investment in a way that very few Realtors can articulate and educates her clients on how to be smart (and patient) to achieve the best possible outcome.

 

Proven Excellence

Dawn McComish's Key West real estate expertise stands as a premier authority in the Florida Keys luxury market, fueled by an unparalleled passion for the island lifestyle. Recognized as the #1 Realtor in Key West for LPT Realty® and ranked as a top buyers' and sellers' agent across Key West and Middle Keys, her proven performance and deep-rooted commitment have made her the go-to resource for clients seeking world-class waterfront living and "tropical anonymity."

View Dawn's Recently Sold Listings 

$100M+

In Home Sales

Top 1%

Key West Realtors

25 Years

Experience in FL Keys

Learn why Dawn McComish is the BEST luxury real estate expert for buying or selling a home in the Florida Keys.

 

Dawn has built a reputation for integrity, reliability, and results. Whether you’re purchasing your first Keys home, investing in a rental property, or relocating full-time, she brings:

  • Expert negotiation skills developed through hundreds of successful transactions

  • Careful attention to due diligence — especially vital for waterfront or historic properties

  • A streamlined, stress-free buying experience from start to finish

In today’s Florida Keys Real Estate market:

  • Inventory is increasing slightly, giving buyers more choice and leverage.

  • Average days on market in areas like Key West are rising (now over 220 days), providing time for thoughtful decision-making.

Dawn helps clients interpret these market dynamics and move confidently toward their goals.

Extensive Network & Exclusive Access to long-standing relationships across the Keys give her clients an unmatched advantage.

 

Her network includes developers, fellow agents, contractors, insurance professionals, inspectors, and property managers.

  • Early access to off-market listings and exclusive opportunities

  • Expert guidance on marina access, boat slips, and waterfront zoning

  • Insights into neighborhoods with high rental potential and long-term value

In Islamorada, for instance, luxury waterfront properties with rental flexibility remain highly sought after thanks to strong tourism demand and premium nightly rates.

Featured on HGTV & 5-Star Rated Everywhere, positioning her as a trusted voice in Florida Keys luxury real estate

 

Her clients consistently rate her 5 stars on every major platform, including:
Zillow, Realtor.com, Trulia, Homes.com, Redfin, RealEstate.com, and Yelp.

These top-tier reviews reflect her commitment to responsive communication, professionalism, and consistently outstanding results.

Exceptional Customer Service is her personalized, client-first approach. She ensures that every buyer feels informed, confident, and supported throughout the process.

 

She helps clients:

  • Navigate local considerations like flood insurance, windstorm coverage, and maintenance costs unique to the islands

  • Choose the right neighborhood for their lifestyle — from vibrant Key West to peaceful Marathon or upscale Islamorada

  • Evaluate long-term value, rental regulations, and resale potential in a limited-inventory market

Whether you’re purchasing a vacation home, a full-time residence, or an investment property, Dawn delivers guidance rooted in care, transparency, and deep market understanding.

Schedule A Consultation

 

Schedule a private chat with Dawn to get the "on-the-ground" truth about the Florida Keys market. Whether you’re hunting for a waterfront retreat or getting ready to sell, Dawn skips the standard sales pitch and delivers the private intelligence you need to make the right move.

Not sure if the timing is right? Reach out for a free, no-obligation home valuation to see exactly where your property stands in today’s market. As a Top 1% specialist, Dawn works closely with you to protect your investment and—for sellers—uses a national marketing reach to ensure you walk away with top dollar. Reach out today and let’s find your version of paradise.

Connect With Dawn

Florida Keys and Key West real estate offer a life built around the water. I’m here to help you navigate it. Whether you are buying your first island getaway or selling a legacy estate, you deserve an advocate who is recognized on the national stage; you need more than a listing agent—you need a local authority with 25 years of "on the ground" experience. The Florida Keys have attracted the world’s most celebrated artists, athletes, writers, and leaders for over a century, and you deserve the best representation as well.

Featured on HGTV House Hunters: My work as a featured agent on House Hunters allows me to showcase the best of the Keys to a global audience, giving my sellers' properties unrivaled exposure.

A National Voice for Keys Real Estate: From Fox Business to top-tier luxury publications, I am the go-to resource for the tax advantages and lifestyle shifts driving today’s market.

25 Years of Local Insight: I don't just pull listings; I provide deep-sea knowledge of every reef, wreck, and residential pocket from Key Largo to Key West.