Dashboard

Realtor® Dawn McComish
Key West Real Estate

Specializing in Luxury Key West Real Estate & Waterfront Homes in the Florida Keys

Price
Beds
Baths
More
Save Search
Key West Real estate agent Dawn McComish

Proven Excellence

Dawn McComish's Key West real estate expertise stands as a premier authority in the Florida Keys luxury market, fueled by an unparalleled passion for the island lifestyle. Recognized as the #1 Realtor in Key West for LPT Realty® and ranked as a top buyers' and sellers' agent across Key West and Middle Keys, her proven performance and deep-rooted commitment have made her the go-to resource for clients seeking world-class waterfront living and "tropical anonymity."

View Dawn's Recently Sold Listings 

$100M+

In Home Sales

Top 1%

Key West Realtors

25 Years

Experience in FL Keys

Top 1% in Sales across The Florida Keys & KEy West Real estate

Of All Brokerages In Monroe County 

Dawn McComish, P.A.

The ‘Singing Realtor’

LPT® Realty

 

Dawn McComish is widely recognized as a top 1% Realtor® in the Florida Keys and Key West real estate. She earned the moniker “The Singing Realtor” by blending her professional real estate expertise with her talent as a vocalist within the local community. This unique title reflects her deep immersion in the vibrant, musical culture of Key West, where she balances high-stakes property intelligence with the creative spirit of the islands. The Florida Keys isn’t just a location; it’s a culture defined by what I call “tropical anonymity.” It’s the only place in the continental U.S. where you can find world-class diving, legendary fishing, and a “flip-flop” billionaire lifestyle where privacy is the local currency.

dawn mccomish singing realtor

“There is a kind of ‘tropical anonymity’ that comes with living in the Florida Keys. Everywhere you go is Keys Casual — t-shirt, shorts, flip-flops — even at the most expensive restaurant.”
Featured Link to FOX Business Article

Dawn McComish, PA

Realtor, LPT® Realty

Find Your Place In Paradise

Explore our Key West real estate to Key Largo communities guides to find the specific neighborhood that aligns with your lifestyle. Whether you are looking for the world-class fishing of Islamorada, the central convenience of Marathon, or the quiet “tropical anonymity” of Cudjoe Key, selecting a region below will show you the most current and relevant listings in that immediate area. This curated selection represents the pinnacle of island living, featuring everything from historic estates to modern architectural masterpieces.

Not sure where to start? Focus your search by selecting the community nearest to your ideal location to see local market trends and available waterfront retreats. Browse this premier portfolio of Florida Keys properties, hand-selected to showcase the best in deep-water access, historic charm, and high-end seclusion. As a Top 1% Key West real estate expert, I provide the exclusive market intelligence and local context behind every home, ensuring you see the true value beyond the listing page.

Key West Real Estate

View Listings

Marathon

View Listings

Lower Keys

View Listings

Key Largo

View Listings

Islamorada

View Listings

Big Coppit Keys

View Listings

Schedule A Consultation

 

Schedule a private chat with Dawn to get the "on-the-ground" truth about the Florida Keys market. Whether you’re hunting for a waterfront retreat or getting ready to sell, Dawn skips the standard sales pitch and delivers the private intelligence you need to make the right move.

Not sure if the timing is right? Reach out for a free, no-obligation home valuation to see exactly where your property stands in today’s market. As a Top 1% specialist, Dawn works closely with you to protect your investment and—for sellers—uses a national marketing reach to ensure you walk away with top dollar. Reach out today and let’s find your version of paradise.

Connect With Dawn

Florida Keys and Key West real estate offer a life built around the water. I’m here to help you navigate it. Whether you are buying your first island getaway or selling a legacy estate, you deserve an advocate who is recognized on the national stage; you need more than a listing agent—you need a local authority with 25 years of "on the ground" experience. The Florida Keys have attracted the world’s most celebrated artists, athletes, writers, and leaders for over a century, and you deserve the best representation as well.

Featured on HGTV House Hunters: My work as a featured agent on House Hunters allows me to showcase the best of the Keys to a global audience, giving my sellers' properties unrivaled exposure.

A National Voice for Keys Real Estate: From Fox Business to top-tier luxury publications, I am the go-to resource for the tax advantages and lifestyle shifts driving today’s market.

25 Years of Local Insight: I don't just pull listings; I provide deep-sea knowledge of every reef, wreck, and residential pocket from Key Largo to Key West.

I’ll Connect Your Florida Keys & Key West Real Estate with Motivated Buyers Nationwide

Trying to decide if it’s the right time to sell your home? Enter your address for a Free Home Valuation Report sent to your inbox and compare other listed and sold properties in your specific area. This custom analysis provides the real-time market data you need to move forward with confidence and maximize your investment.

 

Strategic Seller Representation

When you list with me, your property is positioned as an exceptional asset rather than just another listing. I personally manage every detail—from custom pricing strategies to high-end presentation—to protect your timeline and your privacy. By leveraging exclusive placements in prestige outlets like The Wall Street Journal, The Robb Report, and Mansion Global, I ensure your home reaches the specific, high-intent audience it deserves.

I don’t just put a sign in the yard; I build a comprehensive narrative around your home’s unique value. Whether it’s a historic Key West estate or an Islamorada sportfishing retreat, I use my 25+ years of local insight to highlight the lifestyle features that matter most to buyers. This hands-on approach ensures your property stands out in a crowded market, attracting serious offers while keeping the process smooth and professional.

Maximum Exposure, Minimum Intrusion

My marketing approach combines massive national reach with the absolute discretion required for luxury island real estate. As a Top 1% specialist, I utilize the global network of Lokation Luxury to source qualified buyers while maintaining the “tropical anonymity” that makes the Keys so desirable. My goal is simple: to command top dollar for your investment through a sophisticated strategy that handles the complexities so you don’t have to.

I focus on finding the right buyer, not just any buyer, to minimize unnecessary foot traffic through your home. By pre-qualifying leads and utilizing private virtual tours, I protect your space and your schedule from start to finish. You get the benefit of world-class marketing and a vast professional network, all delivered with the personal touch and local accountability you expect from a longtime Keys resident.

Key West Real Estate: Listing Testimonial

Having met Dawn by accident, we feel we were exceptionally lucky to have done so. We were considering selling our home in Key West but with our confidence in Dawn, we went ahead. She brought us serious buyers, one after another until the perfect Buyer came along within the first two weeks. After that agreement became firm, she couldn’t have been more professional nor knowledgeable in navigating the challenges that inevitably arise with a transaction this size. We would highly recommend Dawn to anyone looking to buy or sell property in the Keys. She has surpassed our vision of the “perfect realtor.” We cannot stress enough Dawn’s experience and knowledge of the market. She is by far the best realtor anyone could possibly hope to find.

Ginger Harrison

Frequently Asked Real Estate Questions